25 Best Christmas Cookie Exchange Recipes

If you’re planning a cookie exchange this holiday, check out these recipes for the best Christmas cookies!

The holidays and cookies go hand in hand, so it’s not time to start a new diet! I don’t know about you, but my favorite thing about the holidays are Christmas cookies! I love baking Christmas cookies with my family, giving them as gifts in those cute holiday tins, and of course, eating them! While I have my favorites, I love trying new Christmas cookie recipes for cookie swaps and Christmas cookie exchanges during the holidays.

If you’re planning a cookie exchange or cookie swap with family, friends or co-workers this holiday season, be sure to check out the best Christmas cookies below. We’ve rounded up our favorite Christmas cookies for you, so you can narrow down which Christmas cookie you will make for your cookie swap this Christmas. When it’s time for your cookie exchange this year, you will be all ready to go with the 25 Best Christmas Cookie Exchange Recipes! 

 

25 Best Christmas Cookies

25 Best Christmas Cookies - Pretty My Party



 

Thumbprint Snowman Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #1: Thumbprint Snowman Cookies: Munchkin Munchies

If you want to make some fun Christmas cookies this holiday, you have to attempt these adorable snowman cookies! Seriously, how cute are these?! Everyone will love these cute Christmas cookies at your cookie swap! Looking for more Christmas desserts, check out these 20 Cute Christmas Desserts.

 

Chocolate Cherry Blossom Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #2: Chocolate Cherry Blossom Cookies: Baking Beauty

You can’t forget about this popular Christmas cookie recipe for chocolate cherry blossoms! They are perfect for a cookie exchange. Plus, they’re red and delicious. You will definitely not go wrong if you make these easy Christmas cookies for your cookie exchange parties.

 

Chocolate Kiss Powder Puff Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #3: Chocolate Kiss Powder Puff Cookies: Averie Cooks

If you’re looking for the best Christmas cookies, look no further than these delicious chocolate kiss powder puff cookies! With a surprise Hershey kiss inside and powdered sugar on the outside, these easy Christmas cookies can be whipped up in no time! What a great Christmas cookie recipe for a cookie exchange.

 

Holiday Confetti Cake Batter Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #4: Holiday Confetti Cake Batter Cookies: Sally’s Baking Addiction 

These holiday confetti cake batter cookies look so festive, don’t you think?! These delicious Christmas cookies feature red and green sprinkles, so this definitely makes them the best Christmas cookies!

 

Chocolate Crinkle Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #5: Chocolate Crinkles: Simply Recipes

These popular chocolate Christmas cookies are loved by many and can certainly be seen on a tray or two at Christmas. These homemade Christmas cookies are easy to make and make the best cookies for a cookie exchange.

 

Melting Snowman Oreos - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #6: Melting Snowman Oreo Balls: The Girl That Ate Everything

These snowman cookies are by far the best Christmas cookies ever!!!! How adorable are these melted snowman cookies?! They are so fun, unique and easy to make. They are definitely our favorite Christmas cookie recipe for a cookie exchange.

 

Grinch Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #7: Grinch Cookies: In Katrina’s Kitchen

These fun Grinch cookies come in a close second for the best Christmas cookie. These easy cake mix cookies will definitely put everyone in the holiday spirit. Make sure these Christmas cookies are on your cookie tray this holiday season. Everyone will love them, especially the kids!

 

Hot Chocolate Cookie Cups - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #8: Hot Chocolate Cookie Cups: The Gunny Sack

Did I forget to tell you the Christmas cookies just keep better and better as you scroll down?! Yes, they certainly do! These adorable hot chocolate cookie cups are so unique and creative. They definitely deserve a spot on the best Christmas cookie list! Walk into a cookie exchange party with these cookies and everyone will think you’re a master baker.

 Turtle Thumbprint Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #9: Turtle Thumbprint Cookies: Tastes Better From Scratch

Filled with caramel and drizzled with melted chocolate, these mouth-watering turtle thumbprint cookies are to die for! If you’re on the hunt for Christmas cookie ideas and love the combination of pecans, chocolate and caramel, these Christmas cookies are your best bet.

 

Christmas Shortbread Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #10: Three-Ingredient Buttery Shortbread Cookies: Chew Out Loud

Who doesn’t love a good buttery shortbread cookie, right?! If you’re looking for easy Christmas cookie recipes, take a look at these Christmas cookies. Add some festive red and green sprinkles for Christmas and you’re all set to take these delicious cookies to your cookie swap.

 

German Chocolate Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #11: German Chocolate Cake Cookies: The Gracious Wife

These delectable German chocolate cake cookies are a delicious combination of sweet and decadent chocolate cookies and gooey caramel coconut pecan frosting! YUM! These chocolate Christmas cookies will definitely not disappoint! It’s like having a small German chocolate cake! If you want to make the best Christmas cookies, put these on your cookie list!

 

 

Vanilla and Chocolate Pizzelles - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #12: Vanilla and Chocolate Pizzelles: Recipe Runner

In case you aren’t familiar with pizzelles they are a flat, round, Italian, waffle type cookie. They are light and delicious and the perfect Christmas cookie for a cookie exchange party. They are easy to make and a unique Christmas cookie for those who aren’t Italian.

 

Melted Snowman Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #13: Melted Snowman Cookies: Home Is Where the Boat Is

Here’s another melted snowman cookie that are fun and easy to make for a cookie swap. These chocolate Christmas cookies are so delicious and will be a hit at any Christmas party. They are easy enough that the kids can help you make them. They will have a blast making these Christmas cookies! Be sure to leave one or two for Santa as well!

 

Chocolate Fudge Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #14: Soft & Chewy Triple Chocolate Fudge Cookies: Roxana’s Home Baking

If you LOVE chocolate Christmas cookies, these soft and chewy triple chocolate fudge cookies will certainly put you under their spell. They are every chocolate lover’s dream and make the best Christmas cookies for any cookie exchange or cookie swap.

 

Peanut Butter Reindeer Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #15: Peanut Butter Reindeer Cookies: Baker Girl

If you want to make the best Christmas cookies for an upcoming cookie exchange party, these adorable peanut butter reindeer cookies will have everyone talking. They are so festive for Christmas and super delicious too. The kids will definitely love these Christmas cookies.

 

Brown Sugar Pecan Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #16: Brown Sugar Pecan Cookies: The Recipe Rebel

We’re not done with the best Christmas cookies just yet! These brown sugar pecan cookies will melt in your mouth. Try your hand at these Christmas cookies for your upcoming cookie exchange parties. This cookie recipe will be a nice change from your typical Christmas cookies.

 

Mom's Russian Tea Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #17Russian Tea Cake Cookies: Crazy For Crust

These Russian tea cake cookies are one of our favorite Christmas cookies to make every year. Filled with pecans and rolled in powder sugar, these cookies will melt in your mouth. Your Christmas cookie platter will not be the same without these Russian tea cake cookies.

 

Salted Peanut Butter Blossoms - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #18: Salted Peanut Butter Blossoms: Your Homebased Mom

Do you LOVE peanut butter? If so, there’s nothing more delicious than these salted peanut butter blossoms. Mix up your Christmas cookie recipes and add in some delicious peanut butter cookies with this Christmas cookie recipe everyone will love.

 

Black Bottom Butterscotch Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #19: Black Bottom Butterscotch Cookies: Something Swanky

These unique Christmas cookies will have everyone wondering how to make them. This cookie is a fabulous combination of a snickerdoodle and a chocolate chip toffee cookie with a thin coating of chocolate on the bottom … SAY WHAT?! These little pieces of heaven definitely make our list for best Christmas cookies!

 

Cookies n' Cream Chocolate Marshmallow Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #20: Chocolate Cookies n’ Cream Marshmallow Cookies: Creme dela Crumb

If you’re a fan of cookies and cream, these will be your new favorite Christmas cookies. These chocolate Christmas cookies filled with marshmallow and cookies and cream, will be a hit at any cookie swap this Christmas.

 

Buckeye Brownie Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #21: Buckeye Brownie Cookies: Tastes of Lizzy T’s

These heavenly chocolate peanut butter cookies are a sweet combination of brownies and buckeyes. Who wouldn’t love these as Christmas cookies?! These sweet cookies are definitely at the top of our best Christmas cookies list. Who can deny the combination of chocolate and peanut butter? It’s the best combination in the whole world.

 

Strawberry White Chocolate Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #22: Strawberry Cookies With White Chocolate Chunks: OMG Chocolate Desserts

Maybe you’re in the mood for Christmas cookies with strawberry. If you are, we have an easy and delicious Christmas cookie recipe for you. These strawberry cookies with white chocolate chunks will be a nice change from all of the chocolate Christmas cookies. Make these delicious Christmas cookies for any cookie exchange or cookie swap.

 

Red Velvet Chocolate Chip Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #23: Red Velvet Chocolate Chip Cookies: Sally’s Baking Addiction

We know anything red velvet, especially for Christmas, will be a total hit. That’s why these red velvet chocolate chip cookies make the best Christmas cookie recipe for a cookie exchange. They are easy and oh so delicious!

 

Kit-Kat Cookies - Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #24: Kit Kat Cookies: Crazy For Crust

Are you a fan of Kit Kat candy? If so, these Kit Kat Cookies will be the best Christmas cookies for you and your family. Chocolate chip cookies are always better with your favorite candy added in and we totally approve of these Kit Kat Cookies for any Christmas cookie exchange.

 

Italian Ricotta Cookies - Best Christmas Cookies

Christmas Cookies Recipe #25: Italian Ricotta Cookies: Love Bakes Good Cakes

These soft and delicious Italian Ricotta cookies will become everyone’s favorite Christmas cookie recipe. Topped with an almond glaze and some sprinkles, these are easy Christmas cookies you can whip up for any cookie exchange or cookie swap. Make these cookies more festive for Christmas by adding red and green sprinkles. And there you have it – easy Christmas cookies for a cookie exchange!

That’s our list of Best Christmas Cookies for a cookie swap or cookie exchange. Which Christmas cookie recipe will you make this holiday? Let us know in the comments below!

For more holiday party ideas, follow us on Instagram @prettymyparty and Pinterest and join us in our private Facebook group

 

Get ready to make the best Christmas cookies with these baking essentials:

Sign up for Amazon Prime and get FREE 2-day shipping on your baking products!

 

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

SaveSave

Do you have these 11 party planning staples?

Stocksy txpdcc3fde7ftv100 small 1419058

Sign up for our newsletter and discover the 11 party must-haves every hostess needs when planning a party. Plus get more party planning tips, tricks and secrets.

We won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit

Comments

  1. I’m obsessed with those little hot cocoa cups!!!

  2. diane constantine says:

    where do i get the recipes for these cookies/ I click on the link, and all i get are pictures.

Leave a Comment

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.